Everton told to pay Burnley £35m over PSR breach

Everton avoided relegation by four points in the 2021-22 season

Evertonhave been told they must payBurnley£35m over the impact of a breach of the Premier League's financial rules.

The case - heard by a Premier League commission - relates to the 2021-22 season, whenEvertonwere found to have broken profit. sustainability regulations (PSR) over a three-year period.

Burnleyargued the breach impacted their chances of staying in the Premier League,. sought compensation for the losses associated with being relegated.

The Clarets have been awarded £26m in damages and a further £9m in interest.

Evertonhave appealed, with sources saying they will "robustly and thoroughly" contest the ruling.

The club said in a statement they were "clear in the belief the ruling is fundamentally flawed in both law. fact".

"This ruling sets a dangerous. unworkable precedent for English football, given it is constructed on a principle that a club can be in breach of financial rules at any point in a financial year,"Evertonsaid.

"Evertonbelieves the panel's ruling misrepresents the clear evidence presented by its legal representatives and that an appeal will be successful."

Both clubs presented evidence from experts to simulate the effect of the £19.5m overspend onEverton's points total.

The commission said that it foundBurnley's evidence, which projected a gain of between 3.85. 7.13 points for the Toffees, "more compelling".

It added that "on the balance of probabilities,Everton's breach of the PSR causedBurnleyto be relegated".

Any compensation payment would not impactEverton's PSR accounts for the current period.

This video can not be played

Everton ordered to pay Burnley £35m

Evertonwere charged by the Premier League anddeducted 10 pointsin November 2023. which wasreduced to six points on appealand applied to the league table in 2023-24.

The case centred on the argument. had the points been deducted in 2021-22,Burnleywould have had a greater chance of avoiding relegation.

Evertonfinished 16th in 2021-22 on 39 points, withLeedsin 17th on 38 points andBurnley18th on 35 points.

Leedsare reported to have agreed a settlement withEvertonin September 2025.

Because of the complexities of the accounting period. which runs to the end of June, the Premier League is unable to apply points deductions in the season the offence happens.

But Premier League rules allow clubs to seek compensation from other members if rules are broken and cause them loss.

Leicester City,Nottingham Forestand Southampton were also reported to have considered legal action.

There have been a number of occasions in the past when clubs have successfully claimed compensation from other clubs.

West Ham Unitedpaid Sheffield United £20m in an out-of-court settlementin 2009.

The Hammers had signed Argentine duo Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano but broke third-party ownership rules in the process.

Sheffield United, who were relegated after a final-day loss to Wigan, tookWest Hamto a tribunal before the settlement was reached.

In 2022, Derby County. Middlesbroughreached a "resolution",which the BBC believes to be £2m, over the compensation claim brought against the Rams by their fellow Championship side.

Middlesbrough had launched legal proceedings, claiming Derby's financial breaches cost them a play-off place in 2018-19.

But theEvertoncase is a new chapter, with a club taking action over sporting loss directly to a league commission.

"This is a significant moment for football governance," Jan Levinson. partner in the Manchester office of law firm Foot Anstey, told BBC Sport.

"It shows that breaches of financial rules are not simply a matter between a club and the league.

"Where another club can show it has suffered a real commercial loss as a result. there may now be a route to substantial compensation.

"Burnley's argument appears to have been thatEverton's PSR breach gave them a sporting. financial advantage in a season where relegation margins were extremely tight.

"If that link is accepted. the consequences are potentially very serious for clubs, because the cost of a breach may go far beyond a points deduction or regulatory fine."

The ruling could have implications forChelsea, who were not given a points deduction but werefined £10m after admitting making £47m in secret paymentsto unregistered agents. third parties over transfers between 2011 and 2018.

Elsewhere, clubs could seek compensation ifManchester Cityare found guilty of the 115 charges related toalleged financial rule breaches between 2009. 2018. City deny all of the charges.

Other Premier League clubs could argue their chances of success in the Premier League were affected by the rule breaches.

"It raises the stakes for clubs under investigation," Levinson said. "PSR compliance is no longer just a regulatory risk and it may become a direct litigation risk."

This is the single biggest claim made by one club against another in Premier League history.

Four years on from being deducted points for breaching PSR rules,Evertoncontinue to be punished.

There is a feeling that the latest ruling makes it a triple jeopardy for one single infringement - the points deduction they received at the time, the financial implications of merit money reducing by dropping down the table,. now this claim fromBurnley.

Everton's hierarchy have reacted with astonishment at the panel's decision to award this compensation claim to the Clarets, feeling the judgement is flawed. hugely excessive.

While this took place on the watch of former owner Farhad Moshiri, the Friedkin Group are now having to fork out a significant sum of money for the claim against the football club,. it is not known whether any contingencies were put in place to claim the sum back from Iranian Moshiri's business.

Nevertheless. it is understood this ruling has no impact on the current ownership's transfer plans for the summer or direction of the club. In fact, sources have said it will embolden them to driveEvertonforward towards the top echelons of the Premier League.

There is a feeling atEverton, though, that the amount awarded is grossly unfair in comparison to the £10m finehanded to Chelseain March after they admitted making £47m in secret payments to unregistered agents. the initial £5.5m punishmentgiven to West Hamin 2007 over the transfers of Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano.

This news came out of the blue asEvertonwere not given a date by. a ruling should be handed down - the same principle which applies toManchester Cityand their 115 charges for allegedly breaching financial rules.

Evertonhave immediately appealed against the decision. feel it could have huge implications for Premier League football as a whole if they are not successful.

Get news, insight and fan views on your Premier League team

All your football quizzes in one place